T-Bill Ladder vs Annuity Calculator 2026: Price the State-Tax Edge Before You Commit
Treasury bills are having a moment. With the fed funds target at 3.75% to 4.00% after the September 2026 hike, short T-bills are paying just over 4% and one-year bills above 4.6% — all backed by the full faith of the U.S. government and, critically, exempt from state and local income tax. Fixed annuities, meanwhile, are still advertising 5.80% to 6.30% on five-year MYGAs. On paper the annuity looks unbeatable. On an after-tax, after-state-tax basis, the gap is narrower than the sticker rates suggest — and for savers in high-tax states, sometimes it flips entirely.
This free T-bill ladder vs annuity calculator settles the question with arithmetic instead of marketing. It grows your deposit through a build phase under each asset’s true after-tax rate, taxes the annuity’s gain at the exit the way IRS Publication 550 treats deferred annuity interest, converts both balances into the level monthly income each can sustain over your draw window, and then reports the winner, the margin, the break-even T-bill yield, and the cash value of that state-tax exemption. Because a losing income plan hurts the people who depend on it, the tool also sizes a term-life backstop policy that would replace the monthly shortfall for your family.
How the T-Bill Ladder vs Annuity Calculator Works
Enter your numbers once and the calculator runs both paths to the same endpoint. You control seven inputs, and every output recomputes instantly:
- Deposit — the lump sum you are deploying ($25,000 to $2,000,000).
- T-bill yield — the blended rate on your rolling ladder of bills (4-week through 52-week rungs).
- Annuity rate — the credited rate on the fixed/MYGA alternative.
- Federal and state tax brackets — your marginal combined rate; the state rate applies to the taxable alternatives but never to T-bill interest.
- Build years — how long the money compounds before income starts.
- Draw years — how long you need the monthly income to last.
- Buyer profile — the age, sex, health class, term length and tobacco use used to price the legacy backstop policy.
The engine makes four explicit assumptions, stated plainly so you can judge them: T-bill interest is taxed annually at the federal rate only (state-exempt per TreasuryDirect); the taxable-savings comparison leg is taxed at your combined federal-plus-state rate; annuity interest compounds untaxed through the build phase and is taxed once at the combined rate on the entire gain when the draw phase begins (a conservative single-exit treatment); and both draw phases are modeled as level monthly withdrawals that exhaust the balance over the draw window.
Where Rates Stand in November 2026
The tool ships with rates current to the November 13, 2026 Treasury auction cycle. Update the yield inputs if the market has moved since — the comparison logic does not change, only the numbers.
| 4-week T-bill | 4.02% | Cash parking, full liquidity |
| 13-week T-bill | 4.23% | The classic ladder rung |
| 26-week T-bill | 4.47% | Higher rung, still liquid at roll |
| 52-week T-bill | 4.63% | Longest bill rung |
| Best 5-year CD | 4.50% to 4.95% | Fully taxable at all levels |
| Top 5-year MYGA | 5.80% to 6.30% | Tax-deferred, illiquid, exit penalties |
The default inputs use a 4.45% blended ladder yield (roughly equal weights of 13-week and 52-week bills) against a 5.85% MYGA — mid-pack for the current market. The default buyer is a 60-year-old male, Standard health, 20-year term, which is the profile that prices the heirs’ backstop policy.
The State-Tax Exemption: T-Bills’ Quiet Edge
Interest on Treasury bills, notes and bonds is exempt from state and local income tax in every state — a carve-out that dates back over a century of federal-state tax comity. For a saver in a no-tax state the exemption is worth exactly zero. For a saver paying California’s 9.3% bracket or New York’s 6.85%, it is a permanent, guaranteed yield bonus no bank product can match. The calculator quantifies it directly: it runs a third, hidden leg — the same ladder yield in a fully taxable account — and reports the difference in sustainable monthly income.
| Your state tax rate | T-bill draw (after fed tax) | Same yield, fully taxable | Exemption value |
| 0% (TX, FL, NV…) | $2,928.00/mo | $2,928.00/mo | $0.00/mo |
| 2% | $2,928.00/mo | $2,903.14/mo | $24.85/mo |
| 4% | $2,928.00/mo | $2,878.47/mo | $49.53/mo |
| 6% | $2,928.00/mo | $2,853.98/mo | $74.02/mo |
| 8% | $2,928.00/mo | $2,829.66/mo | $98.33/mo |
| 10% | $2,928.00/mo | $2,805.53/mo | $122.47/mo |
Notice what the exemption does not do: it does not close a 1.4-point rate gap by itself. At the default 5% state rate it is worth about $62 per month of sustainable income. That is real money — roughly $742 a year — but the annuity’s raw rate advantage is bigger. The exemption’s true power shows up when T-bill yields are high and annuity rates are low, or in double-digit state brackets, or when you remember that the annuity’s own gain gets taxed at exit while the T-bill’s tax bill was paid gradually along the way.
Five Scenarios, Side by Side
All rows computed by the same engine that powers the calculator above, on a $250,000 deposit unless noted. The “winner” is whichever asset sustains the higher level monthly draw over the window.
| Scenario | T-bill draw | Annuity draw | Winner | Break-even bill yield |
| Default (4.45% / 5.85%, 22%+5%) | $2,928.00 | $3,418.36 | Annuity +14.4% | 6.55% |
| California (4.45% / 5.85%, 22%+9.3%) | $2,928.00 | $3,379.39 | Annuity +13.4% | 6.40% |
| Inverted rates (6.50% bills / 5.00% MYGA) | $3,406.50 | $3,186.43 | T-bills +6.5% | 5.59% |
| Big pot ($500K, 4.63% / 6.00%, 32%+6%, 7/15) | $4,334.13 | $5,536.76 | Annuity +21.7% | 7.30% |
| Low-tax retiree (4.30% / 5.85%, 12%+0%, 3/5) | $5,119.62 | $5,603.89 | Annuity +8.6% | 6.24% |
Read the third row carefully: it is the entire case for the ladder. When the yield curve rewards short paper — bills at 6.5% while carriers price new MYGA money at 5% — the after-tax comparison flips to the T-bills by more than $200 a month, and the ladder keeps its principal liquid at every monthly roll date. The annuity’s edge in the other rows is compensation for giving up liquidity and accepting surrender charges; the calculator deliberately prices income only, and you should value flexibility separately.
What the Break-Even Yield Teaches
The break-even card answers the question in one number: what would T-bills have to pay to match this annuity? At the default inputs the answer is 6.55% — meaning today’s 4.45% ladder needs another 210 basis points, roughly the kind of bill yields last seen in the early-2000s hiking cycle, before the annuity’s income advantage disappears. Watch how the number moves: a low federal bracket pulls it down toward 6.1%, a 7-year build with a 15-year draw pulls it below the default, and high-tax states nudge it up as the exemption grows. If you believe short rates are headed toward 6% and carriers are about to reprice MYGA money downward, the break-even number is your decision line — you are not choosing between today’s rates, you are betting on which way each leg moves next.
How to Build a Six-Month T-Bill Ladder
- Split the deposit into six equal parts — on $250,000 that is about $41,600 per rung, held at a brokerage that sells Treasuries at auction without a commission.
- Buy bills at staggered maturities — 4, 8, 13, 17, 26 and 52 weeks, so roughly one rung matures every month or two.
- Roll each maturity into the longest rung — when a bill matures, reinvest into a fresh 52-week bill. After the first year every rung earns the long-end rate while still returning cash monthly.
- Set interest to sweep into the next rung — auction purchases can be set to reinvest automatically once (do not set auto-roll forever; you want the chance to reassess rates).
- Track your blended yield quarterly — that blended number is what you plug into this calculator; the 4.45% default approximates an even 13/52-week mix at November 2026 rates.
- Hold to maturity, never trade — bills sold before maturity can lose principal; held to maturity the return is locked at purchase and backed by the U.S. government.
When the Annuity Wins — and When the Ladder Does
Across the plausible November 2026 rate range, the fixed annuity sustains more income in most scenarios, for three structural reasons: its rate is higher to begin with, its interest compounds untaxed during the build phase, and a decade of deferral lets the carrier’s rate work on the government’s tax money too. The ladder wins when short yields spike above the break-even line, when your combined tax rate punishes the annuity’s exit, or when you simply cannot lock money you may need — a surrender-charge schedule is a cost this tool does not even charge the annuity.
Compare Free Life Insurance Quotes
Answer a few questions and see personalized rates from 50+ carriers in about two minutes. No obligation.
Secure form — your information is encrypted and never sold.
- Ladder strengths: daily liquidity at the roll dates, zero state tax, government backing, no surrender schedule, and rate re-set opportunity every few weeks.
- Annuity strengths: higher credited rate today, tax deferral through the build, guaranteed rates for the full term, and optional riders (a guaranteed lifetime withdrawal benefit turns the draw window into a lifetime income floor).
- The honest tiebreaker: if the margin is under about 10% — the calculator’s “close call” band — liquidity and rate outlook, not the income math, should decide.
The Heirs’ Backstop: Closing the Income Gap With Term Life
Here is the question most rate comparisons never ask: what happens to your family if you commit to the losing asset and die partway through the draw window? The survivors live on the smaller draw for years. The calculator prices that shortfall the way an income-replacement planner would — the monthly difference times your draw window, rounded up to the nearest $25,000 of face amount — and then quotes the 20-year level term premium a buyer of your age, sex and health class would pay today to restore it. At the default inputs the gap is $490.37 per month, a $75,000 face amount, and a 60-year-old Standard male prices that backstop at about $56.47 per month. Run the same numbers at age 45 and the backstop costs $13.02 — which is exactly why the DIME coverage method treats income gaps as an insurance problem, not just an investment problem. The cost-of-waiting calculator makes the same point about delay: the gap you leave unfunded gets more expensive to fix every year you wait.
| Buyer age | Male, Standard, 20-yr | Female, Standard, 20-yr |
| 35 | $7.88/mo | $6.15/mo |
| 45 | $13.02/mo | $10.15/mo |
| 55 | $29.67/mo | $23.14/mo |
| 65 | $83.27/mo | $64.95/mo |
Premiums above are for the default $75,000 backstop face on the site’s market-realistic rate table. Your own quote depends on underwriting — the health class quiz shows how much a Preferred class saves, and tobacco use multiplies any premium by roughly 2.8 times.
Limitations and Assumptions
- Level monthly withdrawals that exhaust the balance are a simplification; real ladders get tapped unevenly and real annuitants take irregular distributions.
- The single-exit tax on the annuity ignores basis recovery and §72(e) anniversary-value mechanics; if you fund with after-tax money your real exit tax is lower, which narrows the annuity’s tax drag shown here.
- The tool prices a fixed annuity; MYGA renewal-rate risk at term end is a separate decision — see the MYGA renewal calculator for the renewal-versus-1035-exchange math.
- Ladder yields drift with every auction; the break-even number moves with them. Re-run the tool when rates shift by more than 25 basis points.
- Treasury interest is federally taxable even when state-exempt; municipal alternatives change the comparison entirely and are not modeled.
For the mechanics of Treasury purchases and the state-tax exemption itself, the authoritative sources are TreasuryDirect auction data and IRS Publication 550 (Investment Income and Expenses). For annuity consumer protections in your state, the NAIC consumer resources page is the regulator-level reference.
T-Bill Ladder vs Annuity Calculator
Related tools on this site: the CD ladder vs annuity ladder calculator runs the same comparison for bank CDs, the life insurance in your 60s calculator sizes protection around pension elections and RMDs, and the health class quiz shows how underwriting class changes every premium on this page.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Treasury bill interest really exempt from state tax?
Yes. Interest on U.S. Treasury bills, notes and bonds is exempt from state and local income tax in all 50 states, though it remains fully taxable on your federal return. The exemption is why the calculator runs a separate fully-taxable comparison leg: at a 5% state rate the carve-out was worth about $62 per month of sustainable income on a $250,000 ladder in the November 2026 default scenario.
What rate would T-bills need to beat a 5.85% annuity?
At the default inputs (22% federal bracket, 5% state rate, 5-year build, 10-year draw) the break-even T-bill yield is 6.55%. The number moves with your tax rates and time windows: a 12% federal bracket with no state tax brings it near 6.24%, while a 32% bracket pushes it above 7%.
Why does the annuity usually win on income?
Three structural reasons: the credited rate is higher (5.80% to 6.30% on top 5-year MYGAs versus about 4% to 4.6% on bills in November 2026), interest compounds untaxed during the build phase, and the deferral lets more principal compound over time. The offsetting costs — surrender charges, lost liquidity, and an exit tax on the entire gain — are exactly what the ladder avoids.
When does the T-bill ladder beat the annuity?
The ladder wins when short-term yields rise above the break-even line while annuity rates lag (the tool’s inverted-rate scenario: bills at 6.5%, MYGAs at 5.0%, T-bills win by 6.5%), in very high state-tax states where the exemption compounds, and whenever liquidity matters more than the last fraction of yield.
How is the heirs’ backstop coverage amount calculated?
The tool multiplies the monthly income gap by your draw window, rounds up to the nearest $25,000, and quotes the level term premium for that face amount using your age, sex, health class, term length and tobacco status. At the default inputs the $490.37 monthly gap across 10 years produces a $75,000 policy costing about $56.47 per month for a 60-year-old Standard male.
Does this calculator include surrender charges on the annuity?
No, and that bias favors the annuity side of the comparison. Real MYGA surrender schedules can run 5% to 9% in the early years, so if you might need the money before the term ends, the ladder’s advantage is larger than the tool’s income-only math shows.
Ready to price the backstop behind whichever asset you choose? Compare free life insurance quotes from 50+ top-rated carriers and lock the income gap closed in minutes.
For a deeper dive, see life insurance ladder strategy calculator — it covers the details most families overlook.